A Dive into Time: Reviewing Doctor Who: Fear Death by Water
As an avid fan of Doctor Who, my excitement peaked when I picked up Fear Death by Water by Emily Cook. The concept of a Doctor-only story set against the backdrop of a revered historical figure was intriguing, especially following Season 2’s heated finale. I approached this novel with a heart full of hope, yet by the end, I found myself grappling with a blend of disappointment and confusion.
From the outset, it’s clear that Cook aimed for ambition. Capturing the essence of the beloved Time Lord is no small feat, and I couldn’t help but appreciate her effort. However, I was struck by the characterization of the Doctor, which felt mismatched. Rather than the unique essence of the 15th Doctor, Cook often painted him with strokes reminiscent of the 11th Doctor. His silliness, his boisterous nature—it all felt more like a guise to mask deeper traumas, something quite representative of Eleven rather than Fifteen.
One quote encapsulated this confusion particularly well: “If he was honest with himself, there was a part of him that got a kick out of danger, a thrill out of saving lives.” While this notion is certainly relatable across incarnations, it resonated strongest with the 11th Doctor’s motivations. The 15th Doctor’s journey, steeped in family dynamics, diverges from this path; his struggles center more on connection than existential musings about heroism.
Cook’s prose poses another hurdle for reading enjoyment, presenting vague clichés that detract from the narrative’s emotional impact. For instance, phrases like “the Doctor’s hero instincts surged” and the nearly tautological “she breathed air that smelled of scent, not of the sea” often lulled me out of the moment. I found myself longing for a more nuanced expression that could do justice to the thrilling depths of the story.
Yet, there were glimmers of brilliance, particularly in the subplots. The character development surrounding Grace was a highlight, and the historical setting showcased Cook’s thorough research. The backdrop felt authentic and well-constructed—elements that, although commendable, couldn’t quite rescue the entire narrative.
In all honesty, Fear Death by Water felt like a miss for me. The writing style didn’t lend itself to the richness of the Doctor’s character or the compelling themes of humanity and heroism. Cook had a story full of potential but struggled to capture the emotional depth that has made Doctor Who so beloved across generations.
Despite my critiques, I recommend this book to die-hard Whovians who enjoy dissecting character tropes and narrative structures. For those seeking a perfect portrayal of the Doctor or a seamless narrative, this might not hit the mark. But for fans of the series, it’s a chance to engage in a conversation about what makes a Time Lord tick—an exploration worth having even if the execution falters.
As I closed the book, I reflected on how Fear Death by Water invited me to grapple with my expectations of the Doctor while serving as a gentle reminder of how intricate storytelling can be. After all, it’s the ups and downs of a story that often lead us deeper into an exploration of ourselves, just as the Doctor does in his travels across time and space.
Discover more about Doctor Who: Fear Death by Water on GoodReads >>