Book Review: Everyone Is Lying to You by Jo Piazza
As someone who frequently finds themselves scrolling through curated Instagram feeds, fascinated yet wary of influencer culture, Jo Piazza’s Everyone Is Lying to You struck a nerve. The title alone felt like a personal invitation to confront the disquieting truths lurking beneath our screens. Combining a gripping murder mystery with incisive cultural commentary, Piazza seamlessly intertwines the two narratives in a way that lingered with me long after I closed the book.
At the heart of the story are Lizzie Matthews and her former best friend, Rebecca "Bex" Sommers, whose lives have drastically diverged since their college days. Lizzie, a struggling magazine writer, seeks a much-needed break and finds herself reconnecting with the now-famous influencer Bex. But what begins as a promising opportunity morphs into something much darker when Rebecca’s husband is found brutally murdered, and Rebecca goes missing. The narrative quickly spirals beyond the typical thriller, digging deep into the grotesque underbelly of social media’s polished facade.
Piazza does a brilliant job of crafting characters that resonate on multiple levels. Lizzie’s evolution from passive observer to active investigator mirrors the disconnection many of us experience in a world dominated by online personas. I found myself rooting for her, even as her desperation blurred her judgment. In one poignant moment, Lizzie asks herself, “Am I really the one chasing the truth, or just another face in the digital masquerade?” This question captures the essence of our relationship with social media—so often we find ourselves consumed by what others present, losing sight of our own realities.
Similarly compelling is Rebecca, whose journey unveils the darker implications of influencer culture. Initially portrayed as the quintessential "tradwife" with the perfect family, Rebecca’s reality is revealed to be heartbreakingly different. Her transformation from college rebel to a woman ensnared in a controlling marriage serves as a stark reminder of what lies beneath social media envy—a cautionary tale that had me reflecting on the often-unspoken pressures of perfection.
Piazza’s writing style is conversational yet incisive, beautifully mirroring the fast-paced, addictive nature of social media itself. Her use of short, punchy sentences evokes the feeling of scrolling through feeds, capturing that barrage of information that leaves us feeling connected yet isolated. It’s a stylistic choice that resonates deeply, especially when Lizzie becomes almost unhealthily preoccupied with her rising follower count amid the murder investigation.
One of the strongest elements in Everyone Is Lying to You is its adept critique of gender dynamics in the influencer economy. Piazza boldly highlights how vulnerable women can become pawns in a game rigged against them, profiting the very systems that exploit their insecurities. This creates an uneasy sense of familiarity that many readers will recognize, making the novel not just an engaging thriller but a perceptive commentary on contemporary life.
However, it’s worth noting that while the plot captures our attention, there are moments when the twists feel a bit formulaic, and some character motivations can seem underdeveloped. Yet, the thematic richness of the narrative more than compensates for these minor hiccups.
In conclusion, Everyone Is Lying to You isn’t just for thriller aficionados; it’s a thought-provoking exploration of our fragile digital lives. It’s a must-read for anyone grappling with the pervasive influence of social media on identity and relationships. Jo Piazza crafts an unsettling mirror reflecting our anxieties about authenticity, connection, and the often tumultuous journey of self-discovery. This novel left me questioning what it means to be truly connected, and I suspect it will do the same for you. If you’re ready to dive into a tale that is both entertaining and reflective of our times, then pick up this book—it’s a ride you won’t want to miss!
Discover more about Everyone Is Lying to You on GoodReads >>