Review of First Lie Wins by Claire McFall
Ever picked up a book that whispers intrigue with its very title? That’s exactly what happened when I stumbled upon First Lie Wins by Claire McFall. Known for her YA thrillers, McFall makes a thrilling leap into adult fiction, and honestly, I was all in for the ride. The book’s premise—of a woman living under a stolen identity in a cat-and-mouse drama—hooked me instantly, proving to be more than just a tale of deception; it turned into a psychological dance that kept me thinking long after I closed the pages.
The story revolves around Evie Porter, who steps into a life that’s not her own, living with boyfriend Ryan Sumner, a wealthy businessman. However, there’s a twist: Evie is essentially a projection, an alias handed to her by her enigmatic boss, Mr. Smith. This initial setup intrigued me, drawing me into Evie’s world of secrets, where every moment teeters between authenticity and façade. The tension builds as Evie navigates her feelings for Ryan, questioning what it means to truly live a lie.
McFall’s writing style deserves special mention. The narrative flows deeply through Evie’s first-person perspective, giving us tantalizing glimpses into her psyche—her struggles, her motivations, and the dichotomy of her existence. The pacing was a pleasant surprise; it’s steady and engaging rather than the frenetic pace often associated with thrillers. McFall manages to balance this with twisty surprises scattered throughout the read, keeping readers on our toes without overwhelming us. And what’s better? The twists were cleverly executed. A few I saw coming, yet many caught me completely off guard, ensnaring my thoughts and ensuring I raced to the finish.
One highlight was certainly how McFall shapes relationships. While their romance could have easily overshadowed the core of the story, it instead acted as a compelling catalyst for the unfolding drama. The nuances in Evie and Ryan’s connection added layers to their characters and kept my investment alive. Their ever-shifting dynamic reflected the wider themes of trust and deception—who’s really conning whom? This idea is exhilaratingly brought to life through the book’s cleverly crafted title.
However, nothing’s without its hiccups. I did find some of the backstory flashbacks, while ultimately essential, initially felt a bit drawn out. The transition from present-day action to past escapades sometimes disrupted the flow, though I appreciated their necessary inclusion by the conclusion. There are also a few minor plot holes and overly familiar character archetypes that can pop up, but frankly, these quirks are often part and parcel of the thriller genre.
In conclusion, if you’re a fan of psychological dramas that require you to engage your mind while slowly unfurling their mysteries, you’ll find First Lie Wins a refreshing read. It’s perfect for those who like their thrillers steady-paced—think of it as an engaging cat-and-mouse dance rather than a race. McFall’s deft hand at characterization and her ability to keep readers guessing offers a delightful experience that is likely to resonate even with those who don’t typically gravitate toward the genre. So, dive in and enjoy the intrigue—just remember, it’s best to go in blind!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I received a complimentary copy through The Pigeonhole, and my review contains my honest opinion. If you’re intrigued by complex identities and layered narratives, don’t miss out on this one!
Connect with me through my blog, The StoryGraph, or social media — I’d love to hear your thoughts!
