Review of Tell Me What You Did by Carter Wilson
When I first stumbled upon Tell Me What You Did, there was something undeniably intriguing about the premise—a true crime podcast host uncovering dark secrets and hidden identities. I’ve been fascinated by true crime stories ever since binge-watching the latest documentary hits, but this time, the stakes felt personal, almost too close for comfort. Carter Wilson beckoned me into a rabbit hole of suspense that I simply couldn’t resist.
From the very first page, the tension crackled like static electricity. Poe Webb, our reluctant protagonist, thrives on inviting strangers to confess their sins in anonymity. But the moment Ian Hindley—a name that sent chills down my spine—appeared in her virtual waiting room, everything shifted. I was drawn into Poe’s world, where boundaries blur between safety and danger, especially as Ian claims to be tied to her mother’s horrifying past. The thrill of watching Poe confront her own demons while unearthing Ian’s truth kept my heart racing.
What struck me most was Poe’s character. She’s complex and layered, embodying an isolation that many of us can relate to. She builds emotional fortresses not just to protect herself, but to stave off vulnerability—a theme that resonated with me deeply. As she navigates her relationship with her assistant, Kip, and her unpredictable encounters with Ian, the emotional weight of her journey felt palpable. One moment, I tried to feel compassion; the next, I was right there questioning her choices.
The narrative moves at a brisk pace, weaving in and out of suspense and introspection effortlessly. Wilson’s writing captures the raw intensity of Poe’s situation, and I found myself completely engrossed, negating all distractions. The way he employs the podcast format serves to elevate the narrative, making it feel almost like I was privy to a live confession. As Poe says, “Now I’m excited,” and believe me, I was right there with her, eagerly flipping pages against the backdrop of muffled anticipation.
One of my personal highlights was the way Wilson refrains from overwhelming readers with backstory—he trusts us to piece together clues, much like Poe does while addressing Ian. Their interactions are chilling, resembling a psychological dance, and I could hear Kip’s voice in my head warning, “This guy freaks me out.” My heart mirrored that tension; it thumped loudly with each revelation.
If you’re a fan of psychological thrillers that dig deep into the human psyche, Tell Me What You Did is a must-read. It’s not just about confessions—it’s a meditation on trauma, secrets, and the lengths we go to keep ourselves safe. This book contains enough twists to keep you guessing until the very end, making it an ideal companion for late-night reading.
For me, this experience was about more than just solving a mystery; it allowed a reflection on my own vulnerabilities and the masks we wear. So, curl up with this page-turner on a stormy night—just make sure to leave the lights on.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Whether you’re a true crime aficionado or a casual reader seeking the next gripping plot, this book is bound to leave its mark on your memory. Trust me—you don’t want to miss the chilling tale that Carter Wilson has brilliantly crafted in Tell Me What You Did.
Discover more about Tell Me What You Did on GoodReads >>
