A Journey Through Time and Mind: A Review of The Once and Future Me by Melissa Pace
There’s something inherently intriguing about novels that grapple with the complexities of the human mind, especially when they transport readers to the confines of an unsettling reality. When I stumbled upon The Once and Future Me, Melissa Pace’s debut, I felt drawn in by the blend of psychological suspense and speculative elements. Set against the backdrop of a 1954 psychiatric hospital, it promised a story that could illuminate our deepest fears and most profound mysteries.
At its core, The Once and Future Me centers around Dorothy Frasier—though she’s convinced that name isn’t hers—who finds herself imprisoned in a psychiatric facility. Diagnosed with schizophrenia, she faces a daily battle, convinced her husband and the hospital staff are mistaken. This struggle to define reality is not only compelling but haunting; readers witness a woman grappling with authoritative voices in her head that lead her to believe she must fulfill an urgent mission. What Pace does brilliantly here is immerse us in the mind of someone living on the edge of reality and perception, capturing the tension of unreliable narration.
One of the novel’s most striking contrasts lies between its two parts. The first section drags somewhat within the beige walls of the hospital, lingering a bit too long on the minutiae of Dorothy’s bleak existence. This part can feel repetitive, with scenes evolving into a mere recitation of medical and institutional despair. Yet, it deliberately sets a tone of frustration that mirrors Dorothy’s own. The caricatures of authority figures serve to illuminate the struggle against oppressive systems, but they occasionally verge on the one-dimensional, distilling the complexity of human interaction into bland tropes.
Then, rhythmically shifting gears, the second part ignites with action and imagination. Here, Dorothy morphs into Beatrix “Bix” Parrish, a fierce soldier navigating a plague-ridden dystopia in 2035. Suddenly, the stakes feel palpably high, with a ruthlessly charismatic cult leader and the looming threat of contagion. This narrative shift is where Pace genuinely shines—her ability to depict frenetic action and chilling desperation encapsulates the reader’s attention and stimulates curiosity.
However, as the plot unfolds, some structural quirks become apparent. The pacing is uneven—while Dorothy’s early days are protracted, the later segments are packed with revelations that feel rushed. It’s as if Pace is eager to catch up with her own ideas, compressing them into a whirlwind of information that sometimes overwhelms rather than enlightens. Still, within this chaotic landscape, there are memorable sequences that sparkle with urgency, underscoring the potential of her storytelling.
The real heart of the book lies in its exploration of identity and the construction of reality—an endeavor that remains crucial in our ongoing conversation about mental health. Pace plucks at the threads of time and experience, leaving readers to question what is real and what is merely a construct of a troubled mind.
Though The Once and Future Me may falter in execution, it also shows immense promise. Fans of speculative fiction, psychological thrillers, or even those intrigued by tales of personal resilience may find something valuable here. The journey through Dorothy’s fragmented reality invites authentic reflection on how we define ourselves and confront the chaos we face.
As I turned the final page, I couldn’t shake the impression that Melissa Pace has just begun to scratch the surface of her potential. I look forward to seeing how she evolves her world and its characters in future works, as I believe her voice is only just beginning to resonate in the literary landscape. Whether you approach it with curiosity about mental health or a thirst for dystopian adventure, The Once and Future Me is a reading experience that promises both contemplation and anticipation for what’s next.
Discover more about The Once and Future Me on GoodReads >>