Book Review: The Tenant by Freida McFadden
I couldn’t resist picking up The Tenant by Freida McFadden. After diving into her earlier works that kept me hooked with twists and turns, I thought, "Maybe this will be the breath of fresh air I need post-exams?" Spoiler alert: it wasn’t quite as invigorating as I’d hoped.
From the get-go, I felt the familiar undertones of McFadden’s style, which we’ve seen in her previous works. The story revolves around Blake, a man whose life seems to crumble as he faces unemployment and financial instability. Enter Whitney, the seemingly chill new tenant, and the stage is set for a classic suburban thriller. But as the plot unfurls, I found myself feeling less intrigued and more… merely entertained.
Themes of an unreliable narrator and the eerie ambiance of secrets lurking in suburbia are beautifully laid out at first. The concept of renting a room to someone who turns out to have more than just a few quirks is universally captivating. However, I felt like the narrative missed the mark when it came to fully exploring the characters. Blake’s whining got a bit tiresome, making me want to shake him into action. Krista? Well, she could have been a backdrop painting for all the relevance she had. Whitney, despite her potential, seemed just there for plot mechanics rather than character development.
McFadden’s signature fast-paced vibe and short chapters kept me reading, and sure, I consumed the book in one sitting. It’s easy to binge-read with her popcorn style, but that doesn’t mean the plot is as satisfying as a gourmet meal. The twist at the end did catch me by surprise, but not in a "jaw-dropping" way; it was more like a "wait, really?" moment. It lacked the emotional punch I yearned for. The story felt a bit… disjointed at times, as if character logic was sacrificed for the sake of plot. And don’t even get me started on the epilogue; it felt like that last pepperoni slice that everyone leaves behind—not terrible, but just not what you were craving.
As I sat with my thoughts after finishing, I couldn’t shake the lingering disappointment. It’s like expecting a gooey chocolate chip cookie only to bite into a raisin one instead. Still pleasant, but it’s just not the experience I wanted.
Would I recommend this book? Maybe, but with reservations. If you’re a die-hard Freida fan desperate for any new thrillers, you might find some enjoyment here. However, if you’re looking for that gripping punch reminiscent of The Housemaid or Inmate, you might want to hold out for her next release (which I, admittedly, will also be reading—it’s a weak spot of mine).
In conclusion, The Tenant has its moments, though it left me with more "meh" feelings than exhilaration. It seems like a lukewarm concoction that strives for complexity but instead delivers comfort in the known. Onward to the next read, cautiously optimistic as always! 📚✨
Discover more about The Tenant on GoodReads >>